The Murderer and the Mind Reader
On Monday, July 9, 1928, four cold-blooded murders were committed on the Booher family farm, just outside the small village of Mannville in central Alberta. The crime shocked the nation, and the police made headlines when they decided to employ a self-proclaimed "mind reader" to help them find the missing murder weapon. It has been called the first criminal case to have ever been solved by a psychic or clairvoyant, but that's not entirely true. In this episode, blending true crime and folklore, we'll look at the legend, the history, and the facts of the case that show how the truth can sometimes be stranger than fiction.
Sources
Berlitz, Charles. “The Case of the Murder-Solving Mentalist.” Charles Berlitz’s World of Strange Phenomena. Fawcett Crest, 1990.
Butts, Edward. Murder: Twelve True Stories of Homicide in Canada. Toronto: Dundurn, 2011.
Clark, Cecil. “Killer trapped!” The Daily Colonist. March 24, 1963.
Colombo, John Robert. True Canadian Ghost Stories, Toronto: Key Porter Books, 2003.
Cooper, Holly. “The Booher Family Murders: Solved by a Psychic?” An Almanac of Infamy (http://infamyalmanac.blogspot.com/2019/07/the-booher-family-murders-solved-by.html), 8 July 2019. Accessed 2021.
Despres, Leon M. “Legal Aspects of Drug-Induced Statements.” University of Chicago Law Review: Vol. 14: Iss. 4, Article 4, pp. 601-616.
Edwards, Frank. “Mentalist Solves Murder.” Sioux City Journal. 4 December 1965, p 1.
Ferguson, Ted. “Reading a Killer’s Mind.” Strange Days: Amazing Stories from Canada’s Wildest Decade. Edmonton: NeWest Press, 2011. P 233-239.
Gaddis, Vincent H. “Mind-Reading Detectives.” Man To Man, Vol. 1, No. 1. December-January, 1949, p 50-51, 58-59
Gier, Mike. “The Man Who Could Read Thoughts.” My Strangest Case. ed. Kurt Singer. New York: Doubleday & Company, p 103-113.
History.com Editors. “A spiteful son kills four in a fit of rage.” History (https://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/a-spiteful-son-kills-four-in-a-fit-of-rage). 13 November 2009. Accessed 2021.
Hogg, Sara Marie. “The Man Who Crawled Inside the Mind of a Murderer.” Caleb and Linda Pirtle – https://www.calebandlindapirtle.com/inside-mind-murderer/ 24 February 2018. Accessed 2021.
McFedries, Archie. “Mind over Murder.” Coronet, August, 1944: Vol. 16, No. 4, pp 131-135
Ogle, Andy. “Unearthing secrets of a family murder.” Edmonton Journal. 29 April 1996, p 1, 7
Robbins, Rob. “Psychic reads killer’s tormented mind.” Weekly World News. 27 September 1988, p 36.
Simmons, C.J. “REX v. BOOHER.” [1928] 4 D.L.R.] Dominion Law Reports. Alberta Supreme Court, Simmons, C.J., September 26, 1928. P 795-797.
Singer, Kurt and Gier, Michael. “A Murder Case.” True Experiences in Telepathy. Toronto: New American Library of Canada, 1967. P 17-31
Thomas, Don. “Good-looking farm-boy was a real killer.” Edmonton Journal. 13 September 1980, p 71.
Townsend, Catherine. “The Booher Family Mass Murder and the Mind Reader Who Helped Crack the Case.” The Lineup (https://the-line-up.com/booher-family-mass-murder), 24 August 2017. Accessed 2022.
Wallechinsky, David. “Maximillian Langsner and the Murderer’s Mind.” The People’s Almanac. New York: Bantam Books, 1981. P 320-322.
Wilson, Colin. The Psychic Detectives. Penguin Group, 1987.
Wilson, Colin. Beyond the Occult: Twenty Years Research. London: Watkins Publishing, 1999, p 3, 144-146
Judicial Decisions on Criminal Law and Procedure. Journal of the American Institute of Criminal Law and Criminology, Vol. 20, No. 2 (August 1929), pp. 303-308. Northwestern University, 10/06/2014.
Journals of the Legislative Assembly of the Province of Alberta: Vol. XXVI, p 20, 39
######
“Berlin Turns to Hypnotism.” The Baltimore Sun, Baltimore, MD. 2 November 1919, p 6.
“Hypnotized cop kills three in audience.” The Courier-News, Bridgewater, NJ. 28 December 1923, p 12.
“Hypnotized policeman kills three.” Evansville Press, Evansville IN. 28 December 1923, p 1.
“Hypnotist says ‘tis fake.” The Kentucky Post and TImes-Star. 28 December 1923, p 9.
“Hypnotist blamed for the slaying of three.” Leader-Telegram, Eau-Claire, WI. 29 December 1923, p 3.
“Hypnotism is more common.” Sioux City Journal, 9 June 1926, p 17 (New York Times)
“Telepathic Powers: Professor Langsner Returns.” Malaya Tribune. 26 March 1927. Reel Number NL3926.
“Dr. Langsner Plans to Give Thrilling Demonstration of Power of Telepathy.” Honolulu Star-Bulletin. 9 November 1927, p 1.
“Skeptics and Others Thrilled Over Langsner’s Mental Science Program.” Honolulu Star-Bulletin. 18 April 1928, p 6.
“Crime Expert to Give Demonstration at Royal Victoria.” Times Colonist, Victoria, BC. 2 July 1928, p 23.
“ROYAL One Night Only…” The Daily Colonist, Victoria, BC. 10 July 1928, p 12.
“Mother, Son, Two Hired Men Murdered.” Edmonton Journal. 10 July 1928, p 1.
“Four Murdered on Alberta Farm; Work of Unknown Maniac?” The Province, Vancouver, BC. 10 July 1928, p 1.
“Manville Slayings a Mystery.” Calgary Herald. 11 July 1928, p 1.
“Four are slain on Alberta farm.” The Montreal Star. 11 July 1928, p 4
“Murder shots fired two hours apart.” Edmonton Journal. 12 July 1928, p 1.
“Gruesome Murder at Manville Baffles All Efforts at Solution.” Calgary Herald. 12 July 1928, p 1.
“Shots were heard by neighbors at 6 o’clock and again at 8 o’clock.” Edmonton Journal. 12 July 1928, p 15
“Alberta Youth Jailed on Charge of Murder.” Star-Phoenix. 18 July, 1928, p 1.
“Vernon Booher Arrested.” Edmonton Bulletin, 18 July 1928, p 1-9.
“Vernon Booher Sent to Trial.” Calgary Herald, 19 July 1928, p 13.
“Hold V. Booher in Provincial Jail.” Edmonton Journal. 19 July 1928, p 13.
“Thought Waves Reveal Murder Clue.” Edmonton Journal. 24 July 1928, p 1.
“Booher boy admits slayings.” Edmonton Bulletin, 24 July 1928, p 1-2
“Solves Murder and Stops Cock Fight by Hypnotic Power.” The Daily Times, Davenport, IA. 27 July 1928, p 8.
“Hypnotist Solves Murder; Stops Two Fighting Cocks.” The Idaho Statesman. Boise, ID. 28 July 1928, p 1.
“Dr. Langsner, marvelous hypnotist of Vienna…” The Press Democrat, Santa Rosa, CA. 28 July 1928, p 1, 6.
“Langsner ‘Solves’ Toronto Mystery.” Edmonton Journal. 10 September 1928, p 1.
“Dr. Langsner Not Worried Over Report.” The Windsor Star. 14 September 1928, p 19
“Langsner Unknown in Vienna.” Calgary Herald. 14 September 1928, p 10.
“Awful Crime Probed.” Edmonton Bulletin. 24 September 1928, p 1.
“Hypnotic Influence Charged By Counsel For Vernon Booher.” Edmonton Journal, 25 September 1928, p 2.
“Langsner On Stand Denies He Employed Hypnotism On Booher.” Edmonton Journal, 26 September 1928, p 2.
“Sisters of Booher on witness stand; deny family rift.” Edmonton Journal. 27 September 1928, p 2.
Tomorrow Night! At the Empire 8:30 p.m.: The Master Mind of All Time…” Star-Phoenix, Saskatoon, SK. 1 November 1928, p 7.
“Langsner aides now in Toronto on Small Search?” Calgary Herald. 20 October 1928, p 9.
“Dr. Langsner’s Psychic Eyes.” The Winnipeg Tribune. 2 November 1928, p 6.
“Attempt to Solve Mystery.” The Recorder. Raymond, AB. 16 November 1928. p 5.
“Dr. Langsner Stunts But Doesn’t Clear Up Toronto Mystery.” Edmonton Journal. 24 November 1928, p 1.
“New Trial for Booher Demanded By Counsel.” Edmonton Journal. 3 December 1928, p 13.
“Vernon Booher Conviction Quashed.” Edmonton Journal. 4 December 1928, p 1.
“Langsner Leaves Canada.” Chronicle. Carbon, AB. 10 January 1929, p 3.
“Another Trial Within a Trial in the Booher Case.” Edmonton Journal. 22 January 1929, p 9-10
“Judge admits Booher statements; Crown scores in Murder trial.” Edmonton Journal. 22 January 1929, p 1.
“Booher III in Court; Near Breakdown.” Edmonton Journal. 23 January, 1929, p 15.
“Booher’s spiritual advisor must answer…” Edmonton Journal. 23 January 1929, p 1, 17
“Government is flayed for using criminologist in Mannville murder case.” Edmonton Journal. 15 February 1929, p 13.
“House misled about Langsner is allegation.” Calgary Herald. 15 February 1929, p 12.
“Govt. lacked B.C. recommend Dr. Langsner, Letters State.” The Lethbridge Herald. 15 February 1929, p 4.
“Dawn breaks as Manville man pays last penalty.” The Edmonton Bulletin. April 24, 1929, p 9
“Young Mannville Murderer Keeps Iron Nerve to Last; Dies at Dawn at Fort Jail.” Edmonton Journal. 24 April 1929, p 1.
“Didn’t Work.” Dayton Daily News. 15 July 1932, p 16.
“Henry Booher.” Edmonton Journal. 28 May 1948, p 20.
“Will He Find It?” The Expositor. Brantford, ON. 20 January 1951, p 4.
“Hugsanalesarinn Sem Lesir Glaepagátur.” Timinn. 10 August 1975, p 10-11.
“Vernon Elwood Booher.” Murderpedia (https://murderpedia.org/male.B/b/booher-vernon.htm). Accessed 2021.
“Hitler’s Black Book – information for Doctor Adolphe Maximilian Langsner.” Forces War Records (https://www.forces-war-records.co.uk/hitlers-black-book/person/1264/doctor-adolphe-maximilian-langsner). Accessed 2021.
